US Supreme Court to Resume ‘Jerusalem, Israel’ Passport Hearing
November 6, 2011The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments Monday for a Jewish boy born in Jerusalem to have his birthplace in Israel’s sovereign capital listed on his U.S. passport.
The case, Zivotofsky v. Clinton, No. 10-699, began with a lawsuit filed in 2003 by Menachem Zivotofsky’s parents, Naomi and Ari.
The couple was incensed when the U.S. State Department refused to allow them to list “Israel” as the boy’s country of birth.
They were instead told that State Department policy requires that only “Jerusalem” be recorded as the place of birth for children born in Israel’s capital, because the United States does not recognize any country as having sovereignty over the city.
The Zivotofskys immediately went to federal court in Washington, D.C. over the passport rule, which insisted on neutrality for Jerusalem.
The judge dismissed the case because, he said, it involved a political issue beyond the judiciary’s power. Upon appeal, a second judge agreed, saying the judicial branch of government cannot order the executive branch to change foreign policy.
Undeterred, the couple has taken the case all the way to the Supreme Court.
Acting Attorney-General Neal Katyal has argued in the Supreme Court that “the status of Jerusalem is one of the most sensitive and long-standing disputes in the Arab-Israeli conflict,” according to Reuters. Katyal contended that the executive branch maintains sole power to decide the policy on passports for U.S. citizens born in Jerusalem, as this is an issue of foreign affairs.
Politico columnist Ben Smith observed over the weekend, “This is, legally, a fight over Congress’s power over the Secretary of State. Symbolically, it’s a back door into one of the charged, “final status” issues of the moribund Israeli-Palestinian peace procese (sic)…”
Smith noted that the stakes are “high, and so small things matter” – including things like the White House erasing the word “Israel” from a photo caption that originally had read “Jerusalem, Israel.” The columnist further investigated to see if the claim was a fluke, but discovered to his surprise, “the Obama effort to scrub it from past documents may be, as White House spokesman Matt Lehrich told Adam Kredo, of that first altered caption, in keeping with ‘U.S. policy for more than 40 years,’ but it also reflects a new level of interest in keeping that policy absolute.”
The hearing on Zivotofsky v. Clinton No. 10-699 resumes Monday. It is expected that the Court will reach a ruling during its current term.
The Palestinian Authority continues to claim a significant portion of Jerusalem – all of the areas restored to Israel’s capital during the 1967 Six Day War, in fact – to create a capital city for its own hoped-for independent state of Palestine.
Refusing to negotiate a final status settlement with Israel, the PA attempted a shortcut and tried to circumvent talks by applying to the United Nations for full membership and recognition as a sovereign state. The U.N. Security Council is due to vote on the matter November 11.
The United States has vowed to exercise its veto as a permanent member of the Council if the resolution is not voted down. France has said it will abstain in the vote.
Similar posts
-
Israel Is Held To A Higher Standard Than Any Country
April 25, 2024In the intricate tapestry of global affairs, one nation stands out for enduring scrutiny and condem...
-
Israel Has The Most Moral Military In The World
April 10, 2024In the heart of a region often riddled with conflict, Israel stands out not only for its technologi...
-
The Resilience of the Israeli People
April 2, 2024Visitors from around the world have seen Hamas's October 7th Massacre's destruction in southern Isr...
-
Israel: Small Size, Big Impact
March 21, 2024Nestled along the eastern edge of the Mediterranean Sea, Israel is a land of immense historical sig...
-
Israelis Are Fighting For Their Lives
February 21, 2024By Jonathan S. Tobin The world looks a lot different from Kibbutz Kfar Aza than it does in the U...
-
Over 2 Million Arabs Live In Israel
January 23, 2024In the complex landscape of the Middle East, where diverse cultures and identities intersect, Israe...
-
'Fauda' Star Idan Amedi Injured Fighting in Gaza
January 8, 2024Despite the severity of his injuries, Amedi's father assured Israeli news channels that his life is...
-
Israel Is A Great Country To Live In
December 28, 2023Nestled at the crossroads of the Middle East, Israel stands as a vibrant and dynamic nation, offeri...