The Aggressive-Passive Reporting On Israel
July 25, 2018
By: Peggy Shapiro
What do these recent headlines about the conflict in Gaza have in common?
“Israel launches waves of strikes across Gaza after soldier killed.”
“Israel carries out Gaza strikes as soldier dies from gunshot.”
“Israel carries out deadly air strikes in Gaza after one of its soldiers is killed.”
“Israeli warplanes pound Gaza in response to burned fields.”
“Israeli kindergarten yard hit by flaming balloon.”
The answer is simple for anyone who has taken English 101 or Intro to Journalism: All actions by Israelis are in the active voice while all actions by Hamas are in the passive voice. The difference is not merely a minor rhetorical point. When we use the active voice, for example “Israel attacked,” we know who committed the action. In the passive voice, “Israeli killed” or “fields are burned,” the agent lurks unidentified.
When a journalist presents all violence committed by Hamas in the passive voice — “Israel hit by rockets” — it leaves the impression that there was no perpetrator. When the same journalist uses the active voice — “Israel carries out strikes” — to describe Israel’s response, it attributes blame to Israel and portrays Israel as the aggressor. Headlining “Soldier dies from gunshot” omits the shooter and implies that no one pulled the trigger. Too many headlines and articles lack explicit reference to an actor unless the actor is Jewish/Israeli.
Sometimes the passive voice is useful when you don’t know who the agent is. The mayor was arrested. We don’t know the officer who arrested him, nor do we need to. However, it is clear to every journalist exactly who fired the weapons that targeted Israelis and who launched the burning kites that destroyed Israeli land and crops. They are just not saying who.
Culprits who use this technique frequently employ the passive voice to blunt criticism. A child with crumbs on his shirt may say, “All the cookies were eaten.” In the same spirit, a new company executive who has just fired a significant number of employees may hope to direct blame away from himself with, “The workforce has been downsized.” In Washington, a hundred million dollar misallocation of funds might be explained as “A mistake was made.” Using the passive voice seeks to evade accusation of responsibility. Political scientist William Schneider referred to this usage of the passive as the “past exonerative” tense. Informed readers should ask why some journalists are choosing language that exonerates Hamas terrorists.
To test the aggressive use of passive language in reporting about Israel, flip the voices. Instead of “Israel carries out deadly air strikes in Gaza after one of its soldiers is killed,” let the headline read, “Following Hamas deadly attack on Israel, Gaza is hit by air strikes.” Change “Israeli kindergarten yard hit by deadly flaming balloon” to “Hamas targets kindergarten with deadly flaming balloon.”
Journalists know that one of the most egregious uses of the passive voice is to hide blame or obscure responsibility, yet some do exactly that when it comes to attacks against Israel. Readers who are aware of such a biased style of reporting understand why George Orwell included the passive voice among the “swindles and perversions” of writing, and they will not be swindled by the aggressive-passive language.
The writer is the executive director of StandWithUs Midwest, an international Israel education organization.
Similar posts
-
Israel: Small Size, Big Impact
March 21, 2024Nestled along the eastern edge of the Mediterranean Sea, Israel is a land of immense historical sig...
-
Israelis Are Fighting For Their Lives
February 21, 2024By Jonathan S. Tobin The world looks a lot different from Kibbutz Kfar Aza than it does in the U...
-
Over 2 Million Arabs Live In Israel
January 23, 2024In the complex landscape of the Middle East, where diverse cultures and identities intersect, Israe...
-
'Fauda' Star Idan Amedi Injured Fighting in Gaza
January 8, 2024Despite the severity of his injuries, Amedi's father assured Israeli news channels that his life is...
-
Israel Is A Great Country To Live In
December 28, 2023Nestled at the crossroads of the Middle East, Israel stands as a vibrant and dynamic nation, offeri...
-
Dear World: I Don't Care
November 2, 2023By Avi Lewis I don’t care that you sympathize with Hamas I know you wouldn’t tolerate any of ...
-
Stand With Israel!
October 17, 2023Stand with Israel. Don't stand with the extreme terror organization Hamas. This is a war about huma...
-
Israel Thanks You For Your Support
October 13, 2023Israel extends its heartfelt gratitude to each and every one of you, dear friends and supporters, f...