There is a Solution to the Demolition Issue
December 6, 2011
As the threat of demolition still hangs over the communities of Migron, Givat Assaf and the Ulpana neighborhood in Beit El, and as Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu is working to establish a legal team to find a solution for the issue, it appears as though a legal solution already exists.
Arabs, backed by extreme leftist group Peace Now, have filed motions to the Supreme Court, saying the communities must be demolished because they were allegedly “built upon private lands.” In at least one case, that of Migron, the Arabs who claimed the land is theirs withdrew their lawsuit when they were unable to present proof of ownership.
There may be good news for the Jewish residents, however: Two of Israel’s leading lawyers, Attorney Dr. Yaakov Weinroth and attorney Dr. Harel Arnon, published a legal opinion on Tuesday, according to which there is already a legal solution to prevent the demolition of the outposts. Weinroth and Arnon found that the solutions are legal under the law which currently applies in Judea and Samaria.
In their opinion, the two lawyers state that, despite the argument for the demolition being that the outposts were built on private land, according to the law in Judea and Samaria there is no need or legal obligation to demolish outposts that were built in good faith. Therefore, in this respect, the Prime Minister does not have to adopt the Supreme Court’s recent ruling which stated that any communities built on private lands should be demolished.
The opinion further states that under the law applicable today in Judea and Samaria, in any case where construction took place in good faith (without knowing that the land had previous owners), there is a solution involving compensation rather than demolition. In some cases, say the attorneys, when the value of the homes exceeds the value of the land, the owner of the homes has the choice of either paying compensation to the owner of the land or demolishing the homes. In other cases, when the value of the land exceeds the value of the homes, the land owner has the choice and can demand that the homes be demolished or force the owners of the properties to purchase the land.
However, the lawyers state that even in cases where the land owner has the choice, so long as he himself does not demand demolition, the authorities cannot choose to demolish homes. The lawyers also note that in Judea and Samaria there is no legal difference between regulated land and land that is not regulated.
The opinion was welcomed by Nachi Eyal, head of the Legal Forum for the Land of Israel and who heads a group called “Legalizing the Communities”.
“The residents’ claims are now legally binding,” Eyal said. “The Prime Minister and government ministers must stop the machine of destruction and bring this legal opinion to the team that the Prime Minister undertook to set up. I’m sure that an examination of the opinion will require the prosecution to inform the Supreme Court that there is a legal solution and that there is no need to demolish homes.”
MK Tzipi Hotovely also welcomed the legal opinion and said, “The opinion only reinforces what we have been arguing since the legal sword was raised over the outposts: The Supreme Court and Peace Now drew a non-binding and untrue legal purpose around their desire to destroy the communities. No more will injustice be done to families using twisted reasons of justice and honesty.”
Similar posts
-
Israel Is Held To A Higher Standard Than Any Country
April 25, 2024In the intricate tapestry of global affairs, one nation stands out for enduring scrutiny and condem...
-
Israel Has The Most Moral Military In The World
April 10, 2024In the heart of a region often riddled with conflict, Israel stands out not only for its technologi...
-
The Resilience of the Israeli People
April 2, 2024Visitors from around the world have seen Hamas's October 7th Massacre's destruction in southern Isr...
-
Israel: Small Size, Big Impact
March 21, 2024Nestled along the eastern edge of the Mediterranean Sea, Israel is a land of immense historical sig...
-
Israelis Are Fighting For Their Lives
February 21, 2024By Jonathan S. Tobin The world looks a lot different from Kibbutz Kfar Aza than it does in the U...
-
Over 2 Million Arabs Live In Israel
January 23, 2024In the complex landscape of the Middle East, where diverse cultures and identities intersect, Israe...
-
'Fauda' Star Idan Amedi Injured Fighting in Gaza
January 8, 2024Despite the severity of his injuries, Amedi's father assured Israeli news channels that his life is...
-
Israel Is A Great Country To Live In
December 28, 2023Nestled at the crossroads of the Middle East, Israel stands as a vibrant and dynamic nation, offeri...